Pergolas: Practical Shade or Just Fancy Lattice?

A pergola is like a pair of cowboy boots—might not be practical, but it sure makes you feel at home.

By

| Published on

pergola, backyard ideas, southern gardening, outdoor living, shade solutions, home improvement, garden design, southern lifestyle, porch living, diy projects

My cousin Earl—bless his heart—once built himself a pergola. Or, as he called it, “one of them fancy porch skeletons.” Earl’s always been one for grand ideas, usually accompanied by a heap of trouble and a six-pack of regret. But this time, I had to admit, it did make his backyard look real nice—at least until the first summer storm came through and it ended up looking like modern art.

Now, folks around here love their porches, and we know how to appreciate a good bit of shade. But a pergola? That’s a whole different story. It’s like the middle child of outdoor structures—not quite a gazebo, not exactly a trellis, but just enough of both to make you wonder if it’s worth the trouble.

The Case for Pergolas

Let me tell you, a pergola does have its charm. There’s something downright pleasant about sitting under those slatted beams with a good book and a glass of sweet tea, watching the wisteria work its way up the posts like it’s got nowhere else to be. If you’re lucky enough to have the right vine—be it jasmine, honeysuckle, or even grapes—you’ll find that a pergola can be a fine addition to your yard, offering a bit of filtered shade without blocking out the sunshine completely.

And let’s not forget the style points. A well-placed pergola can turn an otherwise plain backyard into something straight out of a Southern Living magazine. It’s great for entertaining too—nothing says “Welcome, y’all” quite like twinkling lights strung through the beams and a platter of deviled eggs on the table.

photo of gazebo with curtain and string lights
Pergola at night.

The Drawbacks Nobody Talks About

But now, let’s talk practicalities. If you’re hoping for real, honest-to-goodness shade, you might be disappointed. A pergola gives you more dapples than darkness, and on a sweltering July afternoon in the South, dapples don’t cut it. You might find yourself huddled under it like a man seeking refuge under a lace doily.

Then there’s the upkeep. Wood pergolas, bless ’em, need more attention than a newborn kitten. Between staining, sealing, and the occasional wasp eviction, it’s a wonder anyone keeps up with it at all. And let’s not even talk about those vinyl ones—sure, they’re low-maintenance, but they just don’t have the same soul, you know?

a wooden arbor with pink flowers hanging over it
Garden pergola.

So, Are They Useful or Just Fancy?

Well, friend, that depends on what you’re after. If you want a place to grow climbing roses and set the stage for a dreamy garden party, a pergola might be just the ticket. But if you’re looking for a spot to escape the summer sun, you might want to consider a good old-fashioned porch roof instead.

At the end of the day, a pergola is a bit like a pair of cowboy boots. They might not be the most practical thing you own, but boy, do they make you feel like you belong when you’re under ’em.

A Final Thought

When Earl’s pergola finally gave up the ghost, he replaced it with a plain awning. “Guess I ain’t fancy after all,” he said with a sigh. But you know what? We still sit out there, sipping our tea and watching the fireflies, and it feels just right.