Landscape & Leisure is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, including Botanical Interests seed links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Prices change, so click through to confirm current pricing.
There is a particular satisfaction in the last planting job of the year. The beds are mostly put to bed, the tools are getting their final wipe-down, and then you tuck one more thing into the ground and walk away from it for eight months. Garlic is that planting. It asks almost nothing of you all winter, and it pays you back in July with bulbs you grew yourself.
The catch, in a cold climate, is picking a variety that actually likes your winter. Garlic is not one interchangeable crop. Some types shrug off a frozen January; others sulk through it and come back small. The three varieties below are the ones still in stock at Botanical Interests, and each one earns its place for a different reason. One is the cold-climate workhorse, one is the keeper that lasts nearly a year in storage, and one gives you the most cloves per bulb.
A note on price before you shop: garlic is sold by the bulb, not by the packet. One bulb breaks apart into individual cloves, and every clove you plant becomes a full bulb next summer. At roughly seven dollars a bulb, a single Chesnok Red gives you nine or ten plants, which changes the math considerably.
| Variety | Type | Cloves per bulb | Storage | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chesnok Red | Hardneck | 9–10 | 4 to 6 months | 4.8 out of 5 (60 reviews) |
| Silver White | Softneck | 10–12 | Up to 12 months | 4.4 out of 5 (43 reviews) |
| Sicilian Artichoke | Softneck | 12–20 | Up to 8 months | 4.6 out of 5 (44 reviews) |
Best Overall: Chesnok Red Hardneck Garlic
If you garden where winters bite, start here. Chesnok Red is a hardneck, which is the type built for cold: it produces a curly flower stalk called a scape in spring, its cloves are big and easy to peel, and its flavor is robust enough to hold up to roasting and baking.
The numbers are straightforward. Each bulb holds nine to ten cloves, the bulbs store for four to six months, and fall-planted cloves take 250 to 270 days to mature, which puts harvest in June or July. Buyers rate it 4.8 out of 5 across 60 reviews, the strongest rating of the three varieties here.
Its one trade-off is storage. Four to six months is the shortest keeping time on this list, so Chesnok Red is the garlic you eat first and enjoy most, not the one you count on the following spring. Plant enough of it for winter cooking, and let another variety carry the long storage.
Chesnok Red Hardneck Garlic
The cold-climate workhorse: big easy-to-peel cloves, robust flavor, and the strongest buyer rating here.
Best Keeper: Silver White Softneck Garlic
Silver White is the practical one. It is a softneck silverskin type developed in California, with a mild flavor suited to everyday cooking, and it keeps for up to twelve months when properly cured and stored cool and dry. No other variety here comes close on storage.
Each bulb holds ten to twelve cloves, and because it is a softneck, it braids beautifully — the classic hanging garlic braid is a softneck trick, and Silver White is made for it. It is also a proven performer across cold, hot, and humid climates and coastal areas, so it is a fair choice even where winters are real, though hardneck still gets the first row in the coldest gardens.
The trade-off is flavor and feedback. Mild is a feature when garlic goes in everything, and less of one when you want a bulb with a punch. Its 4.4 out of 5 rating across 43 reviews is also the lowest here, with a recurring theme of uneven results from bulb to bulb. Buy it for the pantry, not for the showpiece row.
Silver White Softneck Garlic
Mild everyday garlic that braids well and keeps up to a year — the pantry staple of the three.
Most Cloves per Bulb: Sicilian Artichoke Softneck Garlic
Sicilian Artichoke is the generous one. Where Chesnok Red gives you nine or ten cloves, this softneck packs twelve to twenty smaller cloves into each head, so a single bulb plants a respectable row all by itself.
The flavor is well-balanced, mild to spicy, and it suits the Mediterranean cooking this variety is named for. The papery skin is white, sometimes streaked with vivid purple, which makes it a handsome bulb as well as a useful one. It stores up to eight months, sitting neatly between the other two, and buyers rate it 4.6 out of 5 across 44 reviews.
The trade-off is clove size. More cloves means smaller cloves, and smaller cloves mean more peeling at the cutting board. If you cook with whole roasted cloves or you dislike fiddly peeling, Chesnok Red’s big cloves will make you happier.
Sicilian Artichoke Softneck Garlic
Twelve to twenty cloves per bulb with a balanced mild-to-spicy flavor — the best value per bulb for planting.
The familiar names that are sold out
Honesty requires a short paragraph here. Several of the best-known garlic names — Music, Nootka Rose, German White, Inchelium Red, and the garlic bundles — are sold out right now. That is the normal shape of the garlic season: the popular varieties sell through in fall, and the catalog narrows to what is left.
Do not let that push you into a variety you do not want. The three above cover the jobs that matter — cold hardiness, long storage, and plenty of cloves — and a bulb in the ground beats a wishlist variety every time. If your heart is set on one of the sold-out names, plan to order early next season rather than settling.
Bottom line
Plant Chesnok Red if your winters are the deciding factor. Add Silver White if you want garlic that lasts until next fall’s harvest. Add Sicilian Artichoke if you want the most plants from the fewest bulbs. All three go in the ground the same way — the timing, depth, and mulch details are in our fall garlic planting guide — and if you are still torn between the two types, our hardneck vs. softneck comparison lays out the trade-offs plainly.
